Friday, March 30, 2012

Sad Song Blogfest

Hey, I was almost all set, putting finishing touches on a post for this week, when I came across this at Jemi Fraser's blog. I thought, why not? I didn't even know it was happening until today, but it apparently originated with L. Diane Wolfe. And if I'm wrong, please correct me. So, without further ado, here it is:
In no particular order:

In Dreams, Roy Orbison.

I’ve featured this one on this blog in the past, but it’s worth it again, just to hear Roy’s incredible voice and range.

Visions of Johanna, Bob Dylan. Some of Dylan’s best lyrical work, as a man struggles between the woman he has (Louise) and the woman he lost (Johanna). Sadly, Dylan’s voice and arrangements don’t really match his lyrics. The version on Blonde on Blonde is just too fast, and is hampered (in my opinion) by a the drums, which belong with a march, not this. But, oh, those lyrics:
Louise, she’s alright, she’s just near
She’s delicate and seems like veneer
She makes it all too concise and too clear, that’s Johanna’s not here
A ghost of electricity howls in the bones of her face
Where these visions of Johanna have now taken my place

This song has what I think of as a great 'late night' feel to it, of darkened rooms and streets, and empty spaces. Here's more:

Lights flicker in the opposite loft
In this room the heat pipes just cough
The country music station plays soft but there’s nothing, really nothing to turn off
Just Louise and her lover so entwined
And these visions of Johanna that conquer my mind

Here's a live performance from 1966.

Visions Of Johanna (Live) [17 by Bob Dylan on Grooveshark

Do You Think It's Alright?/Fiddle About, Pete Townshend, The Who

It's about child molestation. Enough said.

Sing Me Back Home, Merle Haggard. Okay, this is sort of cheating. I know this song through the Grateful Dead, who played it a handful of times on their fabled European tour of 1972. Part of the poignancy for me of this song comes from leaving Long Island to come home after learning my mother had cancer ("treatable," said the doc. When it's 'treatable' and not 'curable', you know what you're dealing with)and having this song be the first one up on the CD player in the car.
Sing me back home, a song I used to hear
Make my old memories come alive
Sing me away, and turn back the years
Sing me back home before I die
Ten minute version incoming:

Sing Me Back Home by Grateful Dead on Grooveshark

Pink Floyd Pink Floyd is arguably the World's Most Depressing Rock & Roll Band, and could probably put any number of songs up here. I'm going with two (six, if you listen to them properly).

First up, is The Great Gig in the Sky from The Dark Side of the Moon. Like the next entry, it really should be part of a three-song segment, with Time and the reprise from Breathe. Nothing like being reminded of the ticking clock and our impending demise, is there? Clare Torry's vocal work on this is outstanding.

Nobody Home, from The Wall. I was 16 or 17 when The Wall came out and I hated Pink Floyd. I've come to appreciate just how good these guys were since then. The Wall is a horrible, brilliant piece of work. Nobody Home is its own song, but is perhaps best-experienced as the coda to the first three songs of the album's second half (Hey, You, Is There Anybody Out There?, Nobody Home - the guitar piece at the end Is There Anybody Out There? may be the loneliest piece of work on record) and finishing with this one. This is desolation.

So, thanks, Diane, for running this hop, and to Jemi for calling it to my attention. What about all of you? Do you like sad music? What are your favorite sad songs?


  1. cannot go wrong with stuff from, the wall.

    Please Check out My Sad Song List...
    Jeremy [Retro-Zombie]
    Visit The Madness:

  2. Love Roy's voice! I like sad music when I'm in the mood for that. I love the powerful emotions it stirs through my insides, lol. :)

  3. Ah the Wall...I totally missed Pink Floyd in mine. Great choices.

  4. Wow. What a diverse selection of songs! Great choices.

  5. Wow, Roy Orbison made me think of his song, Crying - so sad. The others I don't know though.

  6. I love Pink Floyd though! I think The Wall was their most depressing album. It's been ages since I've listened to it. Love Dark Side of the Moon though. Next year that album is 40 years old!

  7. I love songs that trigger a strong emotional response, sad or otherwise. Great post! :)

  8. Oh my, I haven't heard Roy Orbinson in forever. My parents loved him. Pink Floyd is a great band. I learned to love them when my sister married her husband. He's a great fan of theirs and of Ted Nuggent, lol!


  9. Hmm... at the moment all that's coming to mind is "Travelin' Soldier". You have some good picks here, though.

  10. I love Roy Orbison. He is an amazing voice and talent. Still. Nice meeting you :)

  11. The Wall! Yay :) Thanks for the shout out - and you got it right. The blogfest is the brain child of Diane - she's awesome!!! :)

  12. Roy has such a rich voice, great choice.

  13. Pink Floyd made numerous lists, but not mine. You've got a good list here!!

  14. Lotta love for Roy! It's funny, in looking at other lists, I can't believe I missed REM's "Everybody Hurts", which probably made more lists than any other song. I think Pink Floyd is probably the group that made the most lists with the greatest number of songs, which will tell you something...
    Thanks for visiting and commenting, everyone!

  15. Ha! You're dating yourself, Jeff! I used to listen to ALL of them.

    The saddest song I've ever heard is Alice In Chain's Down In A Hole. Especially since Layne Staley accidentally overdosed and died. So very sad.

    Hey, why aren't you doing the A to Z?

    1. Believe it or not, I actually DO listen to current music! I will note I wasn't around when Orbison released "In Dreams."

      As for A-Z, I can't reliably get two posts out each week, never mind 26 in a month!

  16. It depends on my mood. There are definitely times all I want to do is sit around and listen to sad songs. Some of my favorites that I can think of off the top of my head: This Woman's Work by Kate Bush, Storms, by Fleetwood Mac, almost anything by Sara McLachlan, and there are a few good ones by Matchbox 20 too. Wild Horses by the Rolling Stones. Some of them don't necessarily have sad lyrics but they sound sad and soulful.


Alas, due to an overwhelming tide of spam from Anonymous commenters, you must now be a registered user to comment. Sorry, folks, I hope it does not cause inconvenience.